Ruggedly handsome, broad-shouldered and suavely self-assured, Tony Roberts was perhaps everything Woody Allen would have liked to be.
Allen cast Roberts as his tall, confident wingman in no fewer than six of his films, including Annie Hall (1977) in which he portrayed Rob, a Hollywood actor and best friend and tennis partner of Allen’s Alvy Singer. In one memorable scene Allen’s character ranted about finding antisemites everywhere. “You know, I was having lunch with some guys from NBC and I said, ‘Did you eat yet?’ and [they] said, ‘No, Jew?’ Not, ‘Did you?,’ but ‘Jew eat? Jew?’ Not ‘Did you?,’ but ‘Jew eat?’ ”. To which Roberts’s character laconically replied, “You see conspiracies in everything.” The exchange seemed to sum up their relationship — the nervous, insecure Allen and his good-looking, urbane, nonchalant companion trying to keep his tortured friend’s neuroses in check
Best friends off-screen as well as on it, Roberts played similar types in other Allen films. In Stardust Memories (1980), he was a brash, street-smart actor who brought a Playboy model to a film festival while Allen played an angst-ridden move director. In A Midsummer Night’s Sex Comedy (1982), he was a jovial womanising bachelor who declares that “Marriage, for me, is the death of hope” and in Hannah and Her Sisters (1986), he was the effortlessly cool sperm donor who gives Mia Farrow and her infertile husband twin boys. It was not lost on critics that Farrow and Allen, her partner at the time, had attempted to conceive a child together before adopting.
Christopher Isherwood noted that Allen created Roberts’s characters as a foil to “epitomise suave charm in contrast to his own hapless shrubbery”. Roberts himself was less certain about why they worked so well together. “I don’t know what chemistry we lucked upon,” he said. “Woody said people like our schmoozing.. If it was a case of opposites attract and Roberts fulfilled the role of a fantasy alter ego for Allen, then Roberts admitted that in turn there were times when he wished he were Allen.“I would like to have his gift and his genius and his brain. He’s as knowledgeable on most subjects as anyone I know whether you’re talking music or painting or history or politics. That’s a pleasure to be around. But I wouldn’t want his deeper neuroses,” he said of the friend he called “Max” after Allen had asked him not to use his real name in public.
His loyalty to Allen was evident in 2015 when he wrote Do You Know Me?, his autobiography. Several publishers told him they would publish the memoir if it included details about Allen’s personal life. Roberts refused and had the book published independently, forgoing the usual publisher’s advance.
At times when he was not working, he feared that his serial collaborations with Allen might have typecast him. “I was always so vividly the guy Woody wrote that everybody in the business would think of me that way,” he said in 1997. “The persona I was for Woody is a hard thing to break out of.”
The comment suggested a touch of his friend’s insecurity had rubbed off, for in reality, away from the films he made with Allen, he was a prolific actor on stage and screen. Asked if he ever took a vacation, he replied, “No, I crack under leisure.”
His memoir began with a stranger interrupting him one afternoon when he was sitting on a bench in Central Park before saying, “I’ve seen you in something, but I can’t place it. What have I seen you in?” If it was not one of the six films he made with Allen, it might have been in a range of other hit movies from Sidney Lumet’s Serpico (1973), in which he played alongside Al Pacino, to his lead role in Amityville 3-D as the tabloid journalist who buys the infamous haunted house — or in one of the two dozen plays in which he starred on Broadway.
Indeed, it was on the New York stage that Roberts first encountered Allen in 1966 when he auditioned for his play Don’t Drink the Water. It ran for nearly 600 performances over a year and a half, although Roberts claimed that in all that time they hardly exchanged “more than two sentences”.
They grew closer when Roberts appeared on Broadway again in Play It Again, Sam, written by and starring Allen. Roberts received a best actor Tony nomination for his performance and he and Allen reprised their roles in the 1972 movie version directed by Herbert Ross.
David Anthony Roberts was born in Manhattan in 1939, the son of Norma (née Finkelstein), an animator, and Ken Roberts, a radio announcer. His father claimed he knew his son was destined to be an actor when at the age of four he was transfixed by hearing Laurence Olivier in Shakespeare’s Henry V on the radio.
To show his son how a radio station operated, he started taking him to work with him. “We would sit in a room and I would watch grown-ups in suits and ties pretend to be cops, robbers, astronauts, politicians,” recalled Roberts. “They would act in front of a little piece of metal on a stand, but their bodies and their expressions were so invested in their story. It was like watching grown-ups behave like children. That is what did it for me.”
He went on to major in speech and theatre at Manhattan’s High School of Music & Art and at Northwestern University. He later married Jennifer Lyons, a former dancer, but the marriage ended in 1975; he is survived by their daughter, Nicole Burley.. After graduating he returned to New York and his breakthrough came fortuitously in the first Broadway run of Neil Simon’s Barefoot in the Park as the back-up to the understudy to Robert Redford.
When Redford took a two-week vacation, the understudy promptly broke his ankle playing softball. “His break was my big break,” Roberts said. It was while filling in for Redford that Allen saw him and recruited him to appear in Don’t Drink the Water.
“We were friends and had identifiable repartee,” he said of their long collaboration. “The intimacy you saw was real.” There was also some gentle teasing. While making Annie Hall, Roberts returned to his dressing-room trailer to find he had been robbed. The first thing Allen wanted to know was had Roberts’s copy of the script been stolen..
About a week later, they found it in a garbage pail a mile away,” he recalled. “It was my pleasure to make him aware that the thieves thought the script was garbage.”
Tony Roberts, actor, was born on October 22, 1939. He died of lung cancer on February 7, 2025, aged 85